Trends in valuation
Speakers:
Tim Kang
Houlihan Lokey
Smitha Balasubramanian
Lincoln International
John Czapla
VRC
Dwaune Dupree
Eversheds Sutherland
Trends in valuation
Representatives of leading independent valuation firms offered a ground-level view of private credit valuation amid recent market noise. The panel first explained that public BDC discounts to NAV reflect several factors, including dividend coverage, leverage and investor sentiment. They noted that the market is moving through a credit cycle with stress showing in 2021–2022 vintage loans, software borrowers and maturities through 2028.
The group then discussed why funds can mark the same asset differently and emphasized the need to look beyond just the attributes of an investment and consider the underlying nature of an investment’s structure, such as distinguishing PIK elected for growth from PIK driven by liquidity stress. The panel also addressed the shift to monthly or daily NAV, noting that more frequent NAVs do not require mechanically revaluing every asset but do require tight monitoring of investments and considerations such as watchlists and market triggers. Finally, the group discussed the SEC’s focus on valuation processes, including valuation lessons from the SEC’s recent enforcement action against Madison Capital.